Pizza Mill & Sub Factory in Alamogordo

Went to get pizza told them my husband is allergic to mushrooms and they put mushrooms on the pizza. When I called them they told me there is nothing they can do. They have the worst customer service and do not care for their customers

Loved it. The pizza amazing. Plus there's a actual quarter arcade games nextdoor. We had lots of fun!!!

The building is outdated and the inside is a little cramped, but the pizza was pretty darn good! It has a very thin crispy crust. Their subs are absolutely delicious and use thin sliced meats. I was definitely not a fan of their jalapeño poppers - being from NM I have had better. I give this place a 4/5 stars for sure. Overall good food.

Pretty good, my wife girls enjoyed themselves as well as I...

Best pizza place I have found in Alamogordo. They have a variety of food. So far everything has been amazing.

Fun decor. Pretty good pizza too! Maybe the crust was a little thin. I would go again.

Nothing we had was good. The pizza crust foe the 9inch was like the 99 cent pizza you get at walmart. My husband got a steak sandwich and they put tomatoe sauce on it. Was very weird, hardly any meat either. I wouldn't eat there again.

We always enjoy our pizza! The Garbage barge our favorite. Kinda like a Combination,but a whole lot better! Thank you again!

I ordered an Italian sub and a pepperoni pizza had a delicious taste. Sauce was robust and tasted like pizza sauce should. The crust was thin, but not paper thin, it was light and flaky, but not airy. The sub was delicious. Pickle was attached to it with toothpicks. I will go back. The pizza was a little pricey though, but worth it.

The food is superb and I will continue to order for as long as they remain open. But, the attitude of the staff is the worst I have ever experienced, anywhere In any business.

Ordered a small mushroom and olive. Pizza dough was disappointing. It's more like a soda cracker than a proper dough. It was obvious that the shell was pre-made. If you like cheese and crackers ..this is your place!

Ordered the jen which admittedly isn’t a normal pizza. But the entire edges had no cheese or butter and was bland crust only. If it had cheese it would have made it much better.

The food is amazing and the restaurant has a very friendly staff that work fast. The place has a really cool vibe with a few arcade games inside. There is also an "Arcade Dungeon" opening soon that is attached to "The Pizza Mill".

The food is good, I certainly wouldn't call it east coast pizza. Their crust is super thin, like a cookie crust type.

Wasn't our kind of pizza place. Crust was very thin and guy behind the counter was rude. We were the only indoor customers and it took 30+ minutes to get a single pizza. Not enough toppings for what we paid. We had high hopes, but it sat in our fridge an untouched saltine cracker.

We enjoyed their pizzas and salad. They're BIG and we stiffed ourselves with pizza goodness.

We stopped by when we were in town because this place has good reviews. We were pretty disappointed. The pizza was mediocre at best and was overpriced. The staff seemed miserable. It was all just very "meh." I wanted to love it but I couldn't.

The pizza was a little pricy. I'm still a little unsure how to describe the dough. The best I can say is it tasted like a really good frozen pizza. I still ate the entire thing, but I'm not sure if I'd go there again. The Ruben was good though.

Always great! I make a point to stop here when I drive through town. The employees are always awesome and friendly, and the food is always top notch. Great job! I wish yall were still in Artesia and Carlsbad!

Best pizza in town. Seriously!

Very good pizza and the subs as well but I didn't like them as much but is a good place to stop by and eat the have very good waffle fries I recommend going there very good service.

The service was excellent and food was amazing!

I could have had a fantastic experience or maybe aliens stole my baby while I ate there and now I’m furious! You’ll never know for sure! Or maybe just maybe online reviews are not checked for accuracy or authenticity and you should ask an actual person about a restaurant you’re interested in and avoid all the “trolls” and “Karen’s” infesting every corner of the internet these days.

Their Italian sub is the best, antipasto salad was almost as good as the one in cbad was when they were there.

Owner was very rude on more than one occasion. Food is great though. Income for food not the service. Their very dull!!

The food is great and remains consistent over the many years I've eaten here. I like the old movie posters and advertisements they have up all around the place. The detriment to the experience is the attitude of the staff. They are consistently rude and seem like they could not care less about you.

Good pizza. Would be much better if they switched from canned mushrooms.Service was ok, better than the couple next to us received. Do not drink the tea! Stick to the carbonated lot, which sucks for us no soda people. Overall, next time we are in the area, might go back for carry out...no mushrooms.

Was introduced to the Pizza Mill with my first meal being the Belly Bomb!! I cant get enough! They are delicious! Definitely a fan!

Best subs ever! Husband loves the pizza!

The pizza was amazing, it taste absolutely delicious.

Unique little place and there decor at the register mad me laugh because they have post about all of their competition. The food was great and the shake I got was enough for me and my friend.

I love pizza mill especially there chief salads

The workers there are always helpful and happy. The southwest pizza is amazing if you like a thin crust, green chilis, Canadian bacon, sausage you will love it. Try it and enjoy

Awesome pizza and subs.

Numbers 16 and 17 for me. The bread is steamed and the sandwich drenched in italian sauce. Mmmmmm.

Had a blast playing pinball at dungeon arcade next to pizza mill !

Nothing we ordered was good. I have had better frozen pizza. Subs were lousy also. Would not eat there again.

I was sad they didn't have cholula for my cheese pizza. Food and service was great. Place has ice cream and our location doesn't so that was cool. Turkey sandwich was so good my mouth is watering just thinking about it. The building is decorated so well, I love all the RIP signs for other pizza places. Pizza and subs here are amazing, I definitely recommend it if you haven't been to one or even if you've been there before. Good place for groups, kids, families, or couples.

Best food in alamogordo!

I was told this place had decent food but the customer service was a bit lacking. I have to agree, when I ordered from them the person on the phone was a bit sort and just had a bad altitude. The food was not bad at all but wasn't good enough to deal with that kinda of customer service again. Someday in the future I will give them a second try but I have no urge to go back any time soon.

The food was fine. Crust was thin and crumbly. Sweet tea tasted horrid.

Good food ...#16 is an awesome !sub

I haven't eaten at one of these and over 20 years. It was wonderful we had a Reuben sandwich. The bun steamer is a completely different experience than any other sub shop I've ever been to and then we had the cracker crust pizza with hamburger and green chili was amazing 10 thumbs up

I was excited to eat hear. I am in town for work and was looking forward to a different kind of Pizza then the chain restaurants taking over the main road. I ordered a pepperoni, sausage and extra cheese pizza. The wait was short, service great but disappointing pizza. The thin crust was unique, it was cut in to squares but ultimately overpriced. A Red Baron pizza from Wal Mart has better flavor and is much cheaper. The crust had a bland, saltine cracker type flavor. But the pizza was similar to Red Baron falling short of Red Barons flavor. Save your money and go to Wal Mart.

Best pizza in Alamogordo! We really love ordering the "Snappy" which has pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and jalapenos. It is amazing!!!

Quality pizza and really cool atmosphere. Love the arcade games. Sweet Tea was poorly made and soda machine was out of syrup in a couple drinks.

Everything was great decent waiting time I love the garbage barge pizza!

Like the thin flaky crust and the Snappy was even better than the Between the Boarder with green chilies.

I go there almost every day before practice ft or food, there food and ice cream are perfect.

Friendly smiling faces, good food, awesome service